Talk:Guild Raids Achievements

Links

The Raids Achievements and the Guild Achievements have the same name! eeek!
Ok, how could we sort that?

1. Option: Use 1 article for both, i could change the template that if the article if for Raids it get's listed as Guild one too
2. Option: we make disambig pages for all of them and link em to the correct oen each time.

Both ways are ok for me
--    08:16, April 10, 2014 (UTC)

Number 1 could work depending on how it looks. Maybe just a second (optional, obviously) box for the guild achievement, or even just a special guild achievement section after the achievement box that mentions it's also a guild achievement. The latter is simpler, but the former is more robust for any guild achievements that they might add later on that aren't the same as an individual achievement.

The disambig and all that seems too much for too little. If we wanted to go the one-page-per route, I'd say keep the achievements where they are and just name the guild achievements with "(Guild Achievement)" on the end and use a dab on the top of the base achievement to link to the guild version for anyone that lands there. --lordebon (talk) 14:43, April 10, 2014 (UTC)

I just checked it ingame and they don't have the same name and they give differnt points

For example the Raid one is called Bonesnapper Snapper gives 50 points and the Guild Raid one is called Guild: Bonesnapper Snapper gives 10 points

So i guess that will work, looks only akward coz they'll have the same prefix like Guilds then

--    20:50, April 10, 2014 (UTC)

Yeah just saw them in-game myself. TBH it might be better to do name them some other way, I really don't like them going in the Guild: namespace. I'd rather we rename them something like Achievement Name (Guild), e.g., Bonesnapper Snapper (Guild) and then use the altname / display name to display them as Guild: Bonesnapper Snapper. Thoughts? --lordebon (talk) 00:12, April 11, 2014 (UTC)